Home / Questions

EU AI Act fines and penalties: which cap applies to which breach

The EU AI Act does not have a single maximum fine. Article 99 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 sets three ceilings keyed to which obligation was breached, with different arithmetic for SMEs and separate articles for general-purpose AI model providers and for Union institutions.

Auditrek is not open yet, so anything on this page about what it does is what it is being built to do.

Three ceilings, not one

Most people searching for this land wanting one number for a board paper. Article 99 of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 does not offer one. It sets separate maximum administrative fines depending on which part of the Regulation was breached, and the highest tier is reserved for the prohibited practices in Article 5, not for documentation failures.

Two structural points matter more than the headline figure. First, the caps are expressed as a fixed euro amount or a percentage of total worldwide annual turnover for the preceding financial year, whichever is higher, so for a mid-market undertaking the fixed amount is usually the operative ceiling rather than the percentage. Second, these are ceilings, not tariffs. Member States lay down the actual penalty rules and procedural safeguards, and national market surveillance authorities set amounts case by case.

The table below is a structural map of the penalty provisions, not an assessment of any particular system or practice.

Which cap applies to which breach

BreachMaximum administrative fineWhere it sits
Use of an AI practice prohibited by Article 5Up to 35 million euro or 7 percent of total worldwide annual turnover for the preceding financial year, whichever is higherArticle 99(3)
Breach of the other listed obligations, including provider duties under Article 16, deployer duties under Article 26 and the transparency duties in Article 50Up to 15 million euro or 3 percent of total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higherArticle 99(4)
Supplying incorrect, incomplete or misleading information to notified bodies or national competent authorities in reply to a requestUp to 7.5 million euro or 1 percent of total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higherArticle 99(5)
Any of the above where the undertaking is an SME, including a start-upThe same two figures apply, but the lower of the percentage and the fixed amount is the ceilingArticle 99(6)
Breach by a provider of a general-purpose AI model, fined by the Commission rather than a national authorityUp to 15 million euro or 3 percent of total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higherArticle 101
Breach by a Union institution, body, office or agency, fined by the European Data Protection SupervisorUp to 1.5 million euro for prohibited practices and up to 750,000 euro for other breaches in scopeArticle 100

Where records sit in the penalty structure

Record-keeping is not its own penalty tier. Logging obligations reach Article 99 indirectly: automatic logging under Article 12 and log retention by deployers under Article 26 form part of the provider and deployer duties that fall in the 15 million euro or 3 percent band. The distinct exposure is the lower tier in Article 99(5), which is about what you tell an authority. Answering a request for information from an incomplete or unverifiable log is the one route where a records problem converts directly into its own fine.

Article 99(7) also lists what authorities take into account when deciding whether to impose a fine and how much: the nature, gravity and duration of the breach, whether fines have already been applied by other authorities for the same infringement, the size and market share of the operator, the intentional or negligent character of the breach, actions taken to mitigate harm, the degree of cooperation with authorities, the degree of responsibility taking into account the technical and organisational measures implemented, and how the authority came to know of the breach.

Auditrek is built for the evidence side of that list, and nothing more. It ingests inference events over a REST and webhook API, storing input hash, model id and version, output, confidence, timestamp and human override flag as SHA-256 hash-chained append-only records per AI system. A verification endpoint recomputes the chain server-side and returns a tamper status rather than reading a stored flag. A report generator produces PDF and HTML output for a chosen system and date range, structured against Article 12 and 13 fields, with a fixed footer on every page stating that the report does not constitute legal advice and has not been reviewed by qualified regulatory counsel.

Questions

What is the maximum fine under the EU AI Act?

The highest ceiling in Article 99 is up to 35 million euro or 7 percent of total worldwide annual turnover for the preceding financial year, whichever is higher. That tier applies only to the AI practices prohibited by Article 5. Every other breach sits under a lower ceiling, and the widely quoted figures of 30 million euro or 6 percent come from earlier draft versions rather than the adopted Regulation. Read Article 99 in the Official Journal text before citing any figure in a filing.

Which cap applies to a record-keeping or logging failure?

Logging duties are not given a separate penalty band. Automatic record-keeping under Article 12 forms part of the provider obligations in Article 16, and deployer log retention sits in Article 26, both of which fall within the Article 99(4) band of up to 15 million euro or 3 percent of total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher. Whether a given log satisfies a given obligation is a question for a supervisory authority and your counsel, not for a vendor. Our field-by-field walkthrough of Article 12 sets out what the text itself asks a log to contain.

Is the fine a percentage of turnover or a fixed amount?

For most undertakings it is whichever of the two is higher, so the percentage binds large groups and the fixed euro amount binds smaller ones. Article 99(6) reverses that for SMEs, including start-ups: the ceiling is whichever of the percentage or the fixed amount is lower. Turnover is measured on total worldwide annual turnover for the preceding financial year. Both figures are upper limits on what a national authority may impose, not a starting point for negotiation.

Who actually issues EU AI Act fines?

For most operators, penalties are laid down and applied at Member State level, with national market surveillance authorities conducting the enforcement. General-purpose AI model providers are a separate track: Article 101 gives the Commission the power to impose fines on them directly. Union institutions, bodies, offices and agencies are handled by the European Data Protection Supervisor under Article 100, with materially lower ceilings. This means the same breach can be processed by different authorities under different procedures depending on who you are.

Is there a separate penalty for giving an authority the wrong information?

Yes. Article 99(5) sets a distinct ceiling of up to 7.5 million euro or 1 percent of total worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher, for supplying incorrect, incomplete or misleading information to notified bodies or national competent authorities in reply to a request. It is the lowest of the three tiers and the one most directly tied to the quality of your own records. If the underlying log cannot be reconstructed or verified, an accurate reply is hard to produce under a deadline.

When do the penalty provisions start to apply?

The Regulation phases in by chapter under Article 113, and the penalty chapter does not become applicable at the same moment as the high-risk obligations it enforces. Article 101, covering fines on general-purpose AI model providers, is carved out of that earlier date. Because the timeline has been the subject of active proposals and commentary, check the applicability dates against the Official Journal text and any subsequent amending act rather than a secondary summary. Our timeline page covers the phase-in questions in more detail.

Can an audit trail reduce a fine?

No vendor can promise that, and we will not. What Article 99(7) does say is that authorities take into account the technical and organisational measures implemented, the actions taken to mitigate harm, and the degree of cooperation with the authority. Those are evidentiary questions, and evidence is what a signed, verifiable record produces. Auditrek is designed to support documentation of Article 12 and 13 obligations by recording what an AI system did and when, with a server-side chain verification result you can show alongside the report.

How do these fines interact with GDPR fines?

They are separate regimes with separate legal bases, and the same processing can raise obligations under both. Article 99(7) directs authorities to take into account whether administrative fines have already been applied by other market surveillance authorities to the same operator for the same infringement, which is a proportionality factor rather than a bar on parallel enforcement. Because inference payloads from credit, hiring and clinical pipelines routinely carry personal data, the data-protection side of this is not hypothetical. Auditrek rejects payloads containing recognisable raw sensitive fields at ingestion and pseudonymises subject identifiers by default, and no API key or webhook secret is issued for a system until a signed DPA is recorded.

Sources

Join the waitlist

Leave your work email and we will send the payload schema, the verification endpoint documentation and a sample Article 12 and 13 report before you talk to anyone. Pilot cohort conversations start with your own pipeline, not a demo script.

One email when it launches, and one now to confirm your address. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.